I’m going to say right off that I am not the perfect person to review Finders Keephers, and it’s not really a thrift store but a consignment store for designer clothes and accessories. However, I thought I’d mix it up in the interest of variety, and I will proceed as best as I can.
This is a small, well-curated store for the person who wants a gently used Tory Burch dress for $150. Are you that person? It stocks women’s clothing, shoes, jewelry, and lots and lots of purses. In general, my experience is that you pay a premium buying this stuff in person over ebay or other online outlet, but let’s review and you can decide for yourself.
Overall rating: C+
They really only have the four items, so let’s break them down.
1. Clothes. They have a lot of jeans for you if your waist size is between 25 and 28 inches, which I realize is not most people. They had a pair of Lucky jeans for $50 (honestly, they have sales that good for new pairs) and a pair of new-with-tags jeans from Bergdorf’s also for $50, when the original price was $269.00 That said, I’m not sure how old they were. They also had a cute BCBG jacket for $78, which was in excellent condition, but I found a comparable new one on sale for $159. Half price for used is not what I call a good deal. Overall, they did have quite a few new-with-tags items, though, so it may be worth it to you if you find the right thing.
2. Shoes. These used Pucci shoes were selling for $240, and without any trouble whatsoever I located a comparable used pair online for $110, literally half that. I’d be willing to pay a little more locally, since it’s less hassle, and you save on shipping, but that’s a massive difference, and not unusual for consignment shops, in my experience. Similarly, I saw a pair of gray wool (?) Louboutin pumps for $750, and The Real Real offers shoes from the maker for around $400. (Again, I’m not an expert, so maybe the gray ones are especially collectible. But they weren’t even in pristine shape.)
3. Jewelry. Some of the stuff looked really dated to me. I did notice a fairly generic Tiffany silver heart necklace, but I’m not sure who would prefer a used Tiffany necklace for $160 over a brand new heart necklace (obviously a different style) from Tiffany’s for $225, if all you’re trying to do is get something in one of those aqua boxes.
4. Purses. They had a very good selection, some new-with-tags. This Francesco Biasca bag was $260 (originally almost $500, according to the tag) but there are many more inexpensive bags by the same maker on Tradesy for considerably less.Overall, it’s a very lovely store in a neighborhood that’s hard to park in where you’ll pay somewhat more than you really have to. If you’re not a fan of online shopping, it’s an okay option.